<jats:article xmlns:jats="http://jats.nlm.nih.gov" article-type="research-article">
  <jats:notes notes-type="processing">
    <jats:sec xml:lang="en">
      <jats:title>XML Generation Notice</jats:title>
      <jats:p>
                            This is an automatically generated XML version of the publication: 
                            "When does an electron exit a tunneling barrier? - https://doi.org/10.34657/4347", originally published under the license 
                            CC BY-NC 2.0 Unported. 
                            The XML version was generated on 
                            28-08-2026 
                            by Technische Informationsbibliothek (TIB). 
                            In spite of high standards in the development of the script, we cannot outrule the possibility of mistakes in the process of file conversion. 
                            The authors are not responsible for possibly existing mistakes or differences in this XML-version. 
                            The link above directs you to the authorised version of the publication. 
                            If you spot mistakes in the XML-version, please contact us at oarepository@tib.eu. 
                            This XML-Version of the publication "When does an electron exit a tunneling barrier? - https://doi.org/10.34657/4347" is provided "as is", without any guarantee (&#8220;ausdr&#252;cklich oder stillschweigend&#8221;). 
                            TIB does not take responsibility for potential mistakes, missing passages and consequences resulting from this use.
                        </jats:p>
    </jats:sec>
    <jats:sec xml:lang="de">
      <jats:title>Hinweis zur XML-Generierung</jats:title>
      <jats:p>
                            Dies ist eine durch die Technische Informationsbibliothek &#8211; TIB am 28-08-2026 automatisiert erstellte XML-Version der
                            Publikation "When does an electron exit a tunneling barrier? - https://doi.org/10.34657/4347",
                            die unter der Lizenz CC BY-NC 2.0 Unported ver&#246;ffentlicht wurde.
                            Trotz sorgf&#228;ltiger Entwicklung des Skripts k&#246;nnen Fehler im Konvertierungsprozess nicht ausgeschlossen werden.
                            Die Autor*innen der Originalpublikation sind f&#252;r etwaige Fehler/Differenzen in der XML-Version nicht verantwortlich.
                            Die oben verlinkte Datei stellt die autoritative Version der Publikation dar.
                            Hinweise auf Fehler on der XML-Version nehmen wir unter oarepository@tib.eu gern entgegen.
                            Die vorliegende XML-Version der Publikation "https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/20134102019" wird "wie es ist" bereitgestellt,
                            ohne jegliche Gew&#228;hrleistung oder Garantie, sei es ausdr&#252;cklich oder stillschweigend.
                            Die TIB &#252;bernimmt keine Verantwortung f&#252;r etwaige Fehler, Auslassungen oder Folgen, die aus der
                            Nutzung dieser Datei resultieren.
                        </jats:p>
    </jats:sec>
  </jats:notes>
  <jats:front>
    <jats:journal-meta/>
    <jats:article-meta>
      <jats:custom-meta-group>
        <jats:custom-meta>
          <jats:meta-name>xml_created</jats:meta-name>
          <jats:meta-value>28-08-2026</jats:meta-value>
        </jats:custom-meta>
        <jats:custom-meta>
          <jats:meta-name>dc.identifier.uri</jats:meta-name>
          <jats:meta-value>https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/20134102019</jats:meta-value>
        </jats:custom-meta>
        <jats:custom-meta>
          <jats:meta-name>dc.rights.license</jats:meta-name>
          <jats:meta-value>CC BY-NC 2.0 Unported</jats:meta-value>
        </jats:custom-meta>
        <jats:custom-meta>
          <jats:meta-name>dc.relation.doi</jats:meta-name>
          <jats:meta-value>https://doi.org/10.34657/4347</jats:meta-value>
        </jats:custom-meta>
      </jats:custom-meta-group>
      <jats:title-group>
        <jats:article-title>When does an electron exit a tunneling barrier?</jats:article-title>
      </jats:title-group>
      <jats:pub-date date-type="published">
        <jats:day/>
        <jats:month/>
        <jats:year/>
      </jats:pub-date>
      <jats:ref id="">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title>When does an electron exit a tunneling barrier?</jats:article-title>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Shafir</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Soifer</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>H</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Bruner</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>B</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dagan</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Mairesse</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>Y</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Patchkovskii</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>S</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Ivanov</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Smirnova</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>O</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dudovich</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>N</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source/>,
            <jats:volume/>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year/>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:abstract>
        <jats:p>We probe the dynamics of tunnel ionization via high harmonic generation. We characterize the ionization dynamics in helium atoms, and apply our approach to resolve subtle differences in ionization from different orbitals of a CO 2 molecule.</jats:p>
      </jats:abstract>
    </jats:article-meta>
  </jats:front>
  <jats:body>
    <jats:sec>
      <jats:p>Tunneling of a particle through a barrier is one of the most fundamental and ubiquitous quantum processes. When induced by an intense laser field <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b0">[1]</jats:xref>, electron tunneling from atoms and molecules initiates a broad range of processes that evolve on an attosecond time-scale. As the liberated electron is driven by the laser field, it can return to the parent ion and recombine to the initial (ground) state, consequently releasing its energy in an attosecond burst of light <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b1">[2]</jats:xref>. This process, known as High Harmonic Generation (HHG), serves as an excellent spatio-temporal filter for the electron motion.</jats:p>
      <jats:p>In our recent work we have demonstrated how the time at which the electron leaves the atomic barrier can be directly measured <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b2">[3]</jats:xref>. Specifically, we applied a strong laser field to induce tunneling and a weak probe field to steer the tunneled electron. By monitoring attosecond pulses emitted when the liberated electron re-encounters the parent ion, both ionization times and recollision times were reconstructed. We demonstrated high sensitivity of the measurement by resolving subtle delays in ionization times from two orbitals of a CO2 molecule.</jats:p>
      <jats:p>To characterize ionization and recombination times independently, we need a probe that is both perturbative and sufficiently fast to monitor these electron trajectories on a sub-cycle time scale <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b3">[4]</jats:xref>. Such a probe is introduced by adding a weak second harmonic (SH) field, orthogonally polarized to the strong fundamental beam. When the weak field interacts with the free electron it induces a lateral displacement, leading to a reduced recollision probability. The second harmonic field acts as a sub-cycle gate, selecting a narrow range of trajectories that return to the parent ion. As the two-color delay is changed, the gate is shifted within the cycle, and consequently a different ionization window is chosen. An additional gate is induced by the lateral velocity. This velocity as well changes within the optical cycle and depends on both the ionization times and recombination times. In spherically symmetric systems we can extract this velocity by calculating the ratio between even and odd harmonics <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b4">[5]</jats:xref>. This ratio maximizes when the lateral velocity is maximal. The ratio of even to odd EPJ Web of Conferences harmonic amplitudes thus provides an additional independent observable that allows us to disentangle the ionization and recombination times.</jats:p>
      <jats:p>We first generate high harmonics from helium atoms using a strong &#61548;=800 nm fundamental field and a weak second harmonic field at a 1% intensity level. We measure the harmonic intensity as a function of the two-color delay &#61542;. This measurement reflects the 'displacement gate'. Figure 1A presents the normalized harmonic intensities versus the two-color delay, at a field intensity of 3.8x10 14 W/cm 2 . The delay for which the signal is maximal, &#61542; d max , changes with harmonic order, reflecting its dependence on the trajectory. In addition, we measure the ratio between adjacent even and odd harmonics, which reflects the 'velocity gate' (Fig. 1B). Again, we extract the delay &#61542; v max , where this ratio is maximized by the `velocity gate'. The &#61542; -dependence for the two observables is significantly different, reflecting their independence. The perturbative nature of the gate allows us to reconstruct both the ionization time and the recollision time. We calculate both the lateral shift and lateral velocity of the recolliding electron assuming that both times are dictated by the strong fundamental field. Figure 1C presents the reconstructed ionization and recombination times (black dots) together with the predictions of the standard semi-classical model <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b1">[2]</jats:xref> (light dashed curves). The reconstructed recombination times agree well with the semi-classical model. As for the ionization times, a distinct deviation is observed for the lower harmonics: the reconstructed ionization window is about 100 attoseconds shorter than the semi-classical one. This deviation is explained by the stationary solution <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b5">[6]</jats:xref>. When an electron, bound by the ionization potential, enters at some moment t 0 the tunneling barrier induced by the strong laser field, its kinetic energy becomes negative <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b5">[6]</jats:xref>. The stationary solution in this case for the initial velocity and initial time is complex. The quantum exit (ionization) time, t i , is defined as the real part of the complex-valued ionization time. Under our experimental conditions, it differs from the semi-classical exit time by up to a few hundred attoseconds, as shown by the dark solid line in Fig. 1C.</jats:p>
      <jats:p>The next step is the probing of molecular systems where more than one ionization channel can participate in the process <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b6">[7]</jats:xref>. Specifically, we focus on aligned CO 2 molecules where both the HOMO and the HOMO-2 contribute to the tunneling process. Figures 1D, E present the normalized harmonic intensity as a function of the two-color delay &#61542; for CO 2 molecules aligned at 90 and 0 degrees correspondingly. For perpendicular alignment (panel D), a single orbital (HOMO) dominates the signal, therefore the maximum of the signal &#61542; d max changes smoothly with the harmonic order. As we rotate the molecule to be parallel to the laser field, we switch on the contribution of the HOMO-2 (panel E) <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b6">[7]</jats:xref>. In this case we observe a dramatic shift of &#61542; d max by ~&#960;/2 around harmonic 29. This harmonic order corresponds to a minimum observed in the signal, attributed to a destructive interference between the two orbitals <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b6">[7]</jats:xref>. This dramatic shift reveals that two orbitals contribute to the process, resolving subtle delays in their ionization times <jats:xref ref-type="bibr" rid="b2">[3]</jats:xref>.</jats:p>
      <jats:p>In most molecular systems ionization involves attosecond core rearrangements that may lead to a real time-delay associated with non-trivial phases between different tunneling channels. Timeresolving the tunneling dynamics in complex molecular systems will provide a deep insight into fundamental multielectron phenomena --the long-term goal of attosecond science.</jats:p>
    </jats:sec>
    <jats:fig>
      <jats:label>Fig. 1 .</jats:label>
      <jats:caption>
        <jats:p>Fig. 1. A. Displacement gate: normalized harmonic signal as a function of &#61542;. B. Velocity gate: recollision angle as a function of &#61542;. C. Reconstructed ionization and recollision times extracted from A and B. The extracted times (black dots) are compared to the calculated times according to the classical model (light dashed curves) and the quantum stationary solution (dark solid curves). D-E. Displacement gate for CO 2 molecules aligned at 90 (D) and 0 (E) degrees relative to the probe polarization. Black dotted lines mark &#61542; d max .</jats:p>
      </jats:caption>
    </jats:fig>
  </jats:body>
  <jats:back>
    <jats:sec>
      <jats:ref id="b0">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Keldysh</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>L</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>JETP</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>20</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year>1965</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b1">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Corkum</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>PRL</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>71</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year>1993</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b2">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Shafir</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Soifer</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>H</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Bruner</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>B</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dagan</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Mairesse</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>Y</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Patchkovskii</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>S</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Ivanov</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Smirnova</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>O</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dudovich</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>N</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>Nature</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>485</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year>2012</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b3">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Dudovich</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>N</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Smirnova</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>O</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Levesque</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>J</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Mairesse</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>Y</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Ivanov</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Villeneuve</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Corkum</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>Nat. Phys</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>2</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year>2006</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b4">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Shafir</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Mairesse</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>Y</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Villeneuve</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Corkum</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dudovich</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>N</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>Nat. Phys</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>5</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page/> 
            (<jats:year>2009</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b5">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Lewenstein</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Balcou</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Ivanov</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Huillier</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>A</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Corkum</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>PRA</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>49</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page>2117</jats:page> 
            (<jats:year>1994</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
      <jats:ref id="b6">
        <jats:mixed-citation><jats:article-title/>,
            <jats:name><jats:surname>Smirnova</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>O</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Mairesse</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>Y</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Patchkovskii</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>S</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Dudovich</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>N</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Villeneuve</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>D</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Corkum</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>P</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:name><jats:surname>Ivanov</jats:surname>,
        <jats:given-names>M</jats:given-names></jats:name><jats:source>Nature</jats:source>,
            <jats:volume>460</jats:volume>,
            <jats:page>3</jats:page> 
            (<jats:year>2009</jats:year>).
            <jats:pub-id pub-id-type="doi"/></jats:mixed-citation>
      </jats:ref>
    </jats:sec>
  </jats:back>
</jats:article>
